Jennifer E Sherriff, Petrosyan, Artur , Rogall, Dominik , Nora, David , Frahm, Ellery , Lauer, Tobias , Karambaglidis, Theodoros , Knul, Monika V, Vettese, Delphine , Arakelyan, Dmitri , Gur-Arieh, Shira , Vidal-Matutano, Paloma , Morales, Jacob , Fewlass, Helen , Blockley, Simon PE, Timms, Rhys , Adigyozalyan, Ani , Haydosyan, Hayk , Glauberman, Phil , Gasparyan, Boris , and Malinsky-Buller, Ariel . 2024.
“Palaeoenvironmental And Chronological Context Of Hominin Occupations Of The Armenian Highlands During Mis 3: Evidence From Ararat-1 Cave”. Quaternary Science Advances, 13.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.qsa.2023.100122.
Publisher's Version Abstract Archaeological and palaeoenvironmental evidence from the Armenian Highlands and wider southern Caucasus region emphasises the significance of Marine Oxygen Isotope Stage 3 (c. 57–29 ka) as a crucial period for understanding hominin behaviours amidst environmental fluctuations. Ararat-1 cave, situated in the Ararat Depression, Republic of Armenia, presents potential for resolving emerging key debates regarding hominin land use adaptations during this interval, due to its well-preserved lithic artefacts and faunal assemblages. We present the first results of combined sedimentological, geochronological (luminescence and radiocarbon), archaeological and palaeoecological (macrofauna, microfauna and microcharcoal) study of the Ararat-1 sequence. We demonstrate sediment accumulation occurred between 52 and 35 ka and was caused by a combination of aeolian activity, cave rockfall and water action. Whilst the upper strata of the Ararat-1 sequence experienced post-depositional disturbance due to faunal and anthropogenic processes, the lower strata remain relatively undisturbed. We suggest that during a stable period within MIS 3, Ararat-1 was inhabited by Middle Palaeolithic hominins amidst a mosaic of semi-arid shrub, grassland, and temperate woodland ecosystems. These hominins utilised local and distant toolstone raw materials, indicating their ability to adapt to diverse ecological and elevation gradients. Through comparison of Ararat-1 with other sequences in the region, we highlight the spatial variability of MIS 3 environments and its on hominin land use adaptations. This demonstrates the importance of the Armenian Highlands for understanding regional MP settlement dynamics during a critical period of hominin dispersals and evolution.
B Gasparyan, Petrosyan, A, Glauberman, P, Adigyozalyan, A, Arimura, M, Frahm, E, Nahapetyan, S, Arakelyan, D, Sherriff, J, Karampaglidis, T, Krakovsky, M, and Malinsky-Buller, A. 2023.
“Dalarik-1: A New Lower Paleolithic Cave Site In The Republic Of Armenia.”. Aramazd: Armenin Journal Of Near Eastern Studies.
The Early Middle Palaeolithic (EMP) in the Levant presents a unique phenomenon, diverse forms of blade production dominate the technological organization. Contrary to the discontinuous presence of blade production across Eurasia, both before and after the EMP, blades and their by-products were, between 250 and 160,000 years ago, the main "behavioral package" in the Levant region.
The EMP lithic assemblages comprised of several techno-typological traits, the use of Levallois, Laminar, and cores on flakes reduction strategies. Furthermore, it seems that within each single reduction sequence there is versatility, changes which occur between technological concepts allows prolongation of the core’s utility and enhanced control of blank production.
Here, we reassess the assemblages of Abou-Sif, excavated between 1928-1934, and among the first EMP sites excavated and analysed in the region. These lithic assemblages, despite biased collection methods, will contribute to the understanding of the EMP technological organization. These results not only highlight the techno-typological diversity in the mode of production but also reflect the narrow variation that is shared among all known EMP sites. The possible social and demographic implications of this low-diversity within a cohesive geographical and chronological framework will be discussed with regards to the previous Late Lower and later Middle Paleolithic records in the Levant.
S Joannin, Capit, A, Ollivier, V, Bellier, O, Brossier, B, Mourier, B, Tozalakian, P, Colombié, C, Yevadian, M, Karakhanyan, A, Gasparyan, B, Malinsky-Buller, A, Chataigner, C, and Perello, B. 2022.
“First Pollen Record From The Late Holocene Forest Environment In The Lesser Caucasus.”. Review Of Palaeobotany And Palynology , 304.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.revpalbo.2022.104713.
Publisher's Version Abstract Pollen-based vegetation change has been inferred from sediments in Kalavan Red Lake. This small lake is placed in the beech-oak-hornbeam forest, about three kilometres away from the village of Kalavan (Gegharkunik Province of the Republic of Armenia) which is rich with archaeological sites spread in the Barepat River valley spanning from the Palaeolithic period onwards. It has the potential to document the Holocene forest history and climate and human impacts on the Lesser Caucasus. However, this lake happens to be formed by a large landslide.
Pollen and XRF analysis are provided over the last 3800 years. The basal age of the Kalavan sediment approximates the landslide age. This created a not vegetated slope including the lake catchment. Erosion and sedimentation processes brought coarse and heavy minerogenic elements, declining with the catchment revegetation by tall-grassland. This shift in the sedimentation continues, suggesting less erosion in the catchment when an admixture of Quercus and grasslands settled. Starting from 2000 cal. BP, arboreal pollen increases successively thanks to the step afforestation of Quercus, Carpinus orientalis and Fagus.
The comparison with available pollen reconstruction illustrates the uniqueness of the vegetation dynamic recorded at Kalavan. However, the duration of this succession is also questionable. An intermediate hypothesis is proposed: the Kalavan's dynamic is first initiated by the landslide with the tall-grass development, then paced by the regional vegetation dynamic.
Linking vegetation history and erosion with regional climate and archaeological data helps to evidence short-term climate change and human impact. Antique arid phase (2000–1600 cal. BP), the Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice Age affect the vegetation, while demography variations during the Medieval period and Modern Age are shown by habitation and pastoral activity.
Classification of the Paleolithic into Lower, Middle, and Upper has both chronological and cultural meanings serving as a framework for reconstructing cultural evolution and interpreting behavioral processes. Traditionally, the Middle-to-Upper Paleolithic transition in Eurasia is regarded as a bio-cultural turning point, in which local Neanderthals were replaced by incoming Homo sapiens populations, carrying with them a novel technological repertoire. As such, the basic classification of archeological data into broad spatially and temporally coherent blocks is not neutral and disconnected from the paradigmatic view of a “transition” as a developmental event. Initially, the Initial Upper Paleolithic (IUP) was introduced to describe the first cultural stage within the Upper Paleolithic and was later modified to define the cultural transition from the Middle to the Upper Paleolithic. In the last 20 years, the IUP has increasingly been used as a chronological-biological taxonomic unit to describe modern human dispersals into Eurasia, overriding its use within a cultural taxonomic system. In this paper, we evaluate the applicability of the term as a taxonomic unit. The construction of a chronicle and histories, based on well-documented and published data from the late Middle Paleolithic through to the earliest Upper Paleolithic sites across southwest Asia, are used to evaluate the applicability of the term Initial Upper Paleolithic as a taxonomic unit. Within this perspective, the Middle-to-Upper Paleolithic transition is viewed as a social and demographic process that is manifested differently in each of the sub-regions of southwest Asia: the Levant, Southern Caucasus, Armenian Highlands, and the Zagros.
F Romagnoli, Chabai, V, Gravina, B, Hérisson, D, Hovers, E, Moncel, M.-H , Peresani, M, Uthmeier, T, Bourguignon, L, Chacón, M.G , Modica, K. Di , Faivre, J.-P , Kolobova, K, Malinsky-Buller, A, Neruda, P, Garaizar, J.R , Weiss, M, Wiśniewski, A, and Sykes, R.W . 2022.
“Neanderthal Technological Variability: A Wide-Ranging Geographical Perspective On The Final Middle Palaeolithic.”. In Updating Neanderthals, Pp. 163–205. Elsevier.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-821428-2.00012-3.
Publisher's Version Abstract This chapter presents the first collective synthesis of Late Middle Palaeolithic lithic technology (MIS 4–3, ≈ 70–40 ka) from the Altai mountains to the Atlantic coast of Western Europe and the Mediterranean regions of Europe and the Levant. As early as the first half of the 20th century, archaeological debates focused on characterising and interpreting Mousterian techno-typological variability. In recent decades, new data concerning several specific aspects of this question have modified our understanding of Neanderthal technology in terms of lithic economy. This chapter presents the main characteristics of Late Middle Palaeolithic lithic technologies, raw material management, tool forms, and artefact transport patterns. This extensive overview reveals that it is still largely unclear whether spatio-temporal trends in the mosaic of reduction strategies exist, at least during MIS 4–3. Furthermore, disparities in available data from the different geographical areas currently preclude exhaustive interregional comparisons and introduce biases for identifying which variables reflect local adaptations or potentially more general trends. Currently, the degree to which lithic assemblage variability, including retouched stone tools, results from adaptations to different factors remains difficult to reliably assess. These factors include environmental constraints and the influence of local contexts, including the characteristics and accessibility of raw materials and the duration of site occupation. Stone tools assemblages may equally reflect specific traditions of certain Neanderthal populations or groups and communities of practice. Differences in assemblage composition and tool types most likely result from the combined influences of these aspects in association with subsistence strategies and other ecological factors, as well as social structure and other cognitive and behavioural features. Finally, the possibility that the specific dynamics between different Neanderthal populations and between Neanderthals and other human groups affecting aspects of technology cannot be ruled out.
Netta Mitki, Yeshurun, Reuven , Ekshtain, Ravid , Malinsky-Buller, Ariel , and Hovers, Erella . 2021.
“A Multi-Proxy Approach To Middle Paleolithic Mobility: A Case Study From The Open-Air Site Of ‘Ein Qashish (Israel)”. Journal Of Archaeological Science: Reports, 38, Pp. 103088. doi:10.1016/j.jasrep.2021.103088.
Publisher's Version
A. Malinsky-Buller, Glauberman, P. , Ollivier, V. , Lauer, T. , Timms, R. , Frahm, E. , Brittingham, A. , Triller, B. , Kindler, L. , Knul, M.V. V. , Krakovsky, M. , Joannin, S. , Hren, M.T. , Bellier, O. , Clark, A. M. A. , Blockley, S. P.E. , Arakelyan, D. , Marreiros, J. , Paixao, E. , Calandra, I. , Ghukasyan, R. , Nora, D. , Nir, N. , Adigyozalyan, A. , Haydosyan, H. , Gasparyan, B. , Paixaco, E. , Calandra, I. , Ghukasyan, R. , Nora, D. , Nir, N. , Adigyozalyan, A. , Haydosyan, H. , and Gasparyan, B. . 2021.
“Short-Term Occupations At High Elevation During The Middle Paleolithic At Kalavan 2 (Republic Of Armenia)”. Plos One, 16, 2, Pp. e0245700. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0245700.
Publisher's Version Abstract The Armenian highlands encompasses rugged and environmentally diverse landscapes and is characterized by a mosaic of distinct ecological niches and large temperature gradients. Strong seasonal fluctuations in resource availability along topographic gradients likely prompted Pleistocene hominin groups to adapt by adjusting their mobility strategies. However, the role that elevated landscapes played in hunter-gatherer settlement systems during the Late Pleistocene (Middle Palaeolithic [MP]) remains poorly understood. At 1640 m above sea level, the MP site of Kalavan 2 (Armenia) is ideally positioned for testing hypotheses involving elevation-dependent seasonal mobility and subsistence strategies. Renewed excavations at Kalavan 2 exposed three main occupation horizons and ten additional low densities lithic and faunal assemblages. The results provide a new chronological, stratigraphical, and paleoenvironmental framework for hominin behaviors between ca. 60 to 45 ka. The evidence presented suggests that the stratified occupations at Kalavan 2 locale were repeated ephemerally most likely related to hunting in a high-elevation within the mountainous steppe landscape.
Ariel Malinsky-Buller, Glauberman, Phil , Wilkinson, Keith , Li, Bo , Frahm, Ellery , Gasparyan, Boris , Timms, Rhys , Adler, S. D, and Sherriff, E. J. 2020.
“Evidence For Middle Palaeolithic Occupation And Landscape Change In Central Armenia At The Open-Air Site Of Alapars-1”. Quaternary Research, Pp. 1–25. doi:10.1017/qua.2020.61.
Publisher's Version Abstract Here we report the findings from excavations at the open-air Middle Palaeolithic site of Alapars-1 in central Armenia. Three stratified Palaeolithic artefact assemblages were found within a 6-m-thick alluvial-aeolian sequence, located on the flanks of an obsidian-bearing lava dome. Combined sedimentological and chronological analyses reveal three phases of sedimentation and soil development. During Marine Oxygen Isotope Stages 5–3, the manner of deposition changes from alluvial to aeolian, with a development of soil horizons. Techno-typological analysis and geochemical sourcing of the obsidian artefacts reveal differential discard patterns, source exploitation, and artefact densities within strata, suggesting variability in technological organization during the Middle Palaeolithic. Taken together, these results indicate changes in hominin occupation patterns from ephemeral to more persistent in relation to landscape dynamics during the last interglacial and glacial periods in central Armenia.
B Gasparyan, Adler, AS, Wilkinson, KN, Nahapetyan, S, Egeland, CP, Glauberman, PJ, Malinsky-Buller, A, Arakelyan, D, Arimura, M, Dan, R, Frahm, E, Haydosyan, H, Azizbekyan, H, Petrosyan, A, and Kandel, AW. 2020.
“Study Of The Stone Age In The Republic Of Armenia (Part 1 – Lower Palaeolithic)”. Aramazd Armenian Journal Of Near Eastern Studies, X, 1-2, Pp. 1–61.
R Ekshtain, Malinsky-Buller, A, Greenbaum, N, Mitki, N, Stahlschmidt, C, Shahack-gross, R, Nir, N, Porat, N, Bar-Yosef-Mayer, DE, Yeshurun, R, Been, E, Rak, Y, Agha, N, Brailovsky, L, Krakovsky, M, Spivak, P, Ullman, M, Vered, A, Barzilai, O, and Hovers, E. 2019.
Persistent Neanderthal Occupation Of The Open-Air Site Of ‘ Ein Qashish , Israel, Pp. 1–34. doi:10.17605/OSF.IO/AMGQ7.
©2018 Elsevier Ltd The role of demography is often suggested to be a key factor in both biological and cultural evolution. Recent research has shown that the linkage between population size and cultural evolution is not straightforward and emerges from the interplay of many demographic, economic, social and ecological variables. Formal modelling has yielded interesting insights into the complex relationship between population structure, intergroup connectedness, and magnitude and extent of population extinctions. Such studies have highlighted the importance of effective (as opposed to census) population size in transmission processes. At the same time, it remained unclear how such insights can be applied to material culture phenomena in the prehistoric record, especially for deeper prehistory. In this paper we approach the issue of population sizes during the time of the Lower to Middle Paleolithic transition through the proxy of regional trajectories of lithic technological change, identified in the archaeological records from Africa, the Levant, Southwestern and Northwestern Europe. Our discussion of the results takes into consideration the constraints inherent to the archaeological record of deep time – e.g., preservation bias, time-averaging and the incomplete nature of the archaeological record – and of extrapolation from discrete archaeological case studies to an evolutionary time scale. We suggest that technological trajectories of change over this transitional period reflect the robustness of transmission networks. Our results show differences in the pattern and rate of cultural transmission in these regions, from which we infer that information networks, and their underlying effective population sizes, also differed.
M.C. Stahlschmidt, Nir, N. , Greenbaum, N. , Zilberman, T. , Barzilai, O. , Ekshtain, R. , Malinsky-Buller, A. , Hovers, E. , and Shahack-Gross, R. . 2018.
“Geoarchaeological Investigation Of Site Formation And Depositional Environments At The Middle Paleolithic Open-Air Site Of ‘Ein Qashish, Israel”. Journal Of Paleolithic Archaeology, 1, Pp. 32. doi:10.1007/s41982-018-0005-y.